What the cardholder is claiming
“My card was lost or stolen, and I didn’t make this purchase.”
Mastercard’s chip/PIN liability shift for in-person sales. Show the chip was read and the PIN verified where the card required it.
Evidence that wins a Mastercard 4871 chargeback
Start with the required items — they answer the claim directly. Recommended items make a borderline case stronger.
Chip (and PIN) read at the terminal Required
The terminal record shows the card's chip was read, with a PIN where required, so the liability shift doesn't apply.
Sales receipt Recommended
The receipt and order behind this transaction.
Customer correspondence Recommended
Anything showing the cardholder knew of the purchase — never enough alone for fraud.
How to respond to a Mastercard 4871 dispute
- 1
Check the due date in your processor’s dispute dashboard. Responses that arrive late lose, however strong they are.
- 2
Collect the required evidence: chip (and pin) read at the terminal.
- 3
Add what strengthens the case: sales receipt, customer correspondence.
- 4
Write a short response that answers the cardholder’s claim point by point, and cite the exact document and page behind each point.
- 5
Combine it into one clean package and submit it through your processor’s dispute portal.
Writing the response yourself? Use our free chargeback rebuttal letter template.
Why Mastercard 4871 chargebacks happen
- A copied or stolen card was swiped or keyed instead of read by its chip.
- The terminal couldn’t read chips, or fell back to the magnetic stripe.
- A chip-and-PIN card was accepted without a PIN.
How to prevent them
- Use chip-enabled terminals at every till, with PIN support where cards require it.
- Don’t swipe or key a chip card unless the terminal asks you to.
- Keep terminal and receipt records for every in-person sale.
Mastercard 4871 chargeback FAQ
- What does Mastercard reason code 4871 mean?
- Chip / PIN Liability Shift. The cardholder says a lost, stolen or never-received chip card was used in person, where the terminal didn’t complete chip and PIN processing.
- What evidence do I need to win a Mastercard 4871 chargeback?
- Required: chip (and pin) read at the terminal. Also strengthens your case: sales receipt, customer correspondence.
- How do I respond to a Mastercard 4871 chargeback?
- Gather the evidence above, write a response that answers the cardholder’s claim point by point and ties each point to a document, and submit it through your processor’s dispute portal before the due date shown there. Chargeback Warden checks your evidence against the Mastercard 4871 checklist and drafts the cited response for you to approve.
Sources
Check the card network’s current rules for the exact requirements and time limits:
- Mastercard Chargeback Guide