Dispute guide

How to respond to a Shopify chargeback and win it

Last reviewed: · Reviewed by Steve Marshall

If you take payments through Shopify Payments, chargebacks appear in your Shopify admin. Shopify takes the disputed amount and a chargeback fee from your payouts, fills in a response with the order’s details, and sends your answer on to the card network. The cardholder’s bank decides the outcome — not Shopify.

Shopify’s pre-filled response is a starting point, not a winning one. This guide covers each step in the admin and the evidence that answers each kind of dispute. If you take payments through PayPal or another provider, the dispute lives in that provider’s dashboard instead, but the evidence is the same.

Shopify chargebacks: the basics

Where to find it
In your Shopify admin: the order shows a chargeback banner, and every dispute is listed under Shopify Payments.
Deadline
The due date on the chargeback. Shopify sets it ahead of the card network’s own limit and it can’t be extended.
Submissions
One. Once you submit the response, you can’t edit it or add to it.
Who decides
The cardholder’s bank. A decision often takes weeks to a few months.
Fees
A chargeback fee that depends on your store’s country, as does whether it’s returned if you win. Your Shopify Payments settings list it.

Check for Shopify Protect and inquiries first

If an order is covered by Shopify Protect, Shopify handles a fraud chargeback on it for you — the order shows whether it is protected. Some disputes also start as an inquiry: the bank asks for information before filing a chargeback, and no funds are taken yet. A clear answer to an inquiry can stop it becoming a chargeback.

How to respond, step by step

  1. 1

    Open the order and read the reason

    The chargeback shows its reason — such as fraudulent, product not received, not as described, subscription cancelled, credit not processed or duplicate — and the card network. The reason decides what evidence counts.

  2. 2

    Decide whether to counter or accept

    If the customer is right — the order never shipped, or a refund is owed — accept the chargeback and save the time. Counter when you have documents that answer the customer’s claim.

  3. 3

    Check what Shopify filled in

    Shopify pre-fills the response with what it knows: the customer’s details, billing and shipping addresses, the order and its fulfillment and tracking. Check it is right — for example, that the tracking really shows delivery, not just shipment.

  4. 4

    Add the evidence Shopify can’t see

    Shopify only knows what happened inside Shopify. Add the carrier’s proof of delivery, emails and chats from outside Shopify, the product page as it looked when the customer bought, and your policies as they were shown at checkout. Use the checklist below for the dispute type.

  5. 5

    Write a short explanation

    Answer the customer’s claim point by point, and name the document behind each point. A bank analyst should understand your case in a minute.

  6. 6

    Submit before the due date

    Check every file opens and reads clearly, then submit. You can’t change it afterwards, and a late response loses automatically.

  7. 7

    Wait for the bank’s decision

    Shopify emails you when the bank rules. If you win, the disputed amount comes back in a payout.

Writing the explanation yourself? Use our free chargeback rebuttal letter template.

The evidence that wins each kind of dispute

What wins depends on the customer’s claim, which the reason code names. Each reason code’s guide has its full checklist.

Fraud and unrecognized orders

Shopify reasons: fraudulent, unrecognized

  • The card checks from the order’s fraud analysis: address (AVS) and CVV results, and 3D Secure if it ran.
  • The IP address and location behind the order, compared with the billing address.
  • Earlier orders from the same customer that weren’t disputed — for Visa, matching past orders can satisfy Compelling Evidence 3.0.
  • Delivery to the cardholder’s billing address, or proof they used what they bought.
  • Messages showing the customer knew about the order.

Reason codes:Visa 10.4Mastercard 4837Mastercard 4863Amex F29Discover UA02

Product not received

Shopify reason: product not received

  • Carrier tracking showing delivery to the shipping address on the order, with signature or photo if you have it.
  • The order’s fulfillment events from its timeline.
  • For digital products: proof the customer received and opened them.
  • Any message from the customer after delivery.

Reason codes:Visa 13.1Amex C08Discover RG

Not as described or defective

Shopify reason: product not as described

  • The product page as the customer saw it when they bought.
  • Your refund policy, and proof it was shown at checkout.
  • Your messages with the customer — especially a return or replacement you offered.
  • Proof the item matched its description: photos, specifications, quality checks.

Reason codes:Visa 13.3Mastercard 4853Amex C31Discover RM

Subscription cancelled

Shopify reason: subscription cancelled

  • The subscription terms the customer agreed to, and how to cancel.
  • Proof the customer didn’t cancel before this charge, from your subscription app.
  • Renewal reminders or order confirmations you sent.

Reason codes:Visa 13.2Mastercard 4841Amex C28

Credit not processed

Shopify reason: credit not processed

  • Your refund policy as shown at checkout.
  • The refund on the order’s timeline — or why no refund was owed (for example, the return never arrived).
  • Your messages with the customer about the return.

Reason codes:Visa 13.6Amex C02Discover RN2

Duplicate charge

Shopify reason: duplicate

  • Both orders side by side, showing they were separate purchases.
  • A fulfillment for each order.
  • Or, if one was refunded, the refund and its date.

Reason codes:Visa 12.6.1Amex P08Discover DP

Where to find the evidence

The order’s fraud analysis
Address and CVV check results, the IP address and its location.
The order’s timeline
Fulfillment, tracking, refunds, and the emails Shopify sent the customer.
The customer’s page
Their earlier orders, to show a history of undisputed purchases.
Settings → Policies
Your refund and shipping policies — and check they match what checkout showed on the order date.
Outside Shopify
The carrier’s proof of delivery, emails and chats in your own inbox — Shopify doesn’t have these.

Mistakes that lose winnable disputes

  • Submitting Shopify’s pre-filled response as it is. It proves the order exists, not that the customer’s claim is wrong.
  • Tracking that only shows “shipped” or “in transit”. For a not-received dispute you need delivery, to the address the customer gave you.
  • Burying the bank in pages. An analyst reads dozens of cases a day: a short explanation and only the documents that prove it beat a 40-page dump.
  • Submitting before everything is in. You get one submission, so wait for the carrier’s proof of delivery or the customer’s old emails if they are on the way — but not past the deadline.
  • Arguing with the customer in the response. Stick to facts the bank can check, each tied to a document.

Shopify chargebacks FAQ

How long do I have to respond to a Shopify chargeback?
Until the due date shown on the chargeback in your Shopify admin. Shopify sets it ahead of the card network’s own limit, it can’t be extended, and a late response loses automatically.
Can I edit a Shopify chargeback response after submitting?
No. Once submitted, the response goes on to the card network as it is, so make sure you have every document first — but submit before the due date.
Does Shopify decide who wins the chargeback?
No. Shopify passes your response to the card network and the cardholder’s bank decides. Shopify then emails you the outcome.
Does Shopify Protect cover my chargeback?
Only if the order is covered by Shopify Protect and the chargeback is for fraud. The order in your admin shows whether it is protected; if it is, Shopify handles that chargeback for you.
What if my store doesn’t use Shopify Payments?
Then the dispute is handled by the provider that took the payment, such as PayPal or another gateway, in its own dashboard. The evidence that wins is the same, because it depends on the reason code, not the platform.

Your next deadline is already counting down.

Open your first case free and have a cited, ready-to-send evidence package before the clock runs out.

Start your first case free

No card needed · Sign up with Google or email