Dispute guide

How to respond to a Stripe dispute and win it

Last reviewed: · Reviewed by Steve Marshall

When a customer disputes a card payment, Stripe emails you, takes the disputed amount and a dispute fee from your balance, and gives you a date to respond by. Your response goes to the customer’s bank — the bank decides who wins, not Stripe.

You get one submission, so it has to be complete the first time. This guide walks through each step in the Stripe Dashboard and the evidence that wins each kind of dispute.

Stripe disputes: the basics

Where to find it
Stripe Dashboard → Payments → Disputes. Each dispute shows its reason, amount and “Respond by” date.
Deadline
The “Respond by” date on the dispute. Stripe sets it ahead of the card network’s own limit and it can’t be extended.
Submissions
One. You can save evidence and come back to it, but once you submit, it can’t be changed.
Who decides
The cardholder’s bank. A decision often takes weeks to a few months.
Fees
A dispute fee when the dispute opens and, in some countries, a further fee when you counter it. Check Stripe’s pricing page for your country and what is returned if you win.

Inquiries and early fraud warnings come first

Some disputes start as an inquiry: the bank asks questions before filing a chargeback, and no funds are taken yet. A clear answer can stop it going further. Stripe Radar may also send an early fraud warning on a payment; refunding it then usually prevents a chargeback, because once a dispute opens the payment can no longer be refunded through Stripe.

How to respond, step by step

  1. 1

    Read the dispute reason

    Stripe sorts disputes into reasons such as fraudulent, product not received, product unacceptable, subscription canceled, credit not processed and duplicate, and shows the card network’s reason code in the details. The reason decides what evidence counts — look it up before you collect anything.

  2. 2

    Decide whether to counter or accept

    If the customer is right — the order never shipped, or a refund is owed — accept the dispute. It closes as lost without more work or a countering fee. Counter when you have documents that answer the customer’s claim.

  3. 3

    Contact the customer, but don’t try to refund

    Many disputes are misunderstandings. If the customer agrees to withdraw the dispute with their bank, ask them to confirm it in writing and still submit your evidence, including that message — the dispute stays open until the bank closes it.

  4. 4

    Collect the evidence for that reason

    Use the checklist below for the dispute type. Pull what Stripe already has (the payment’s card checks, the customer’s receipt) and add what lives elsewhere: carrier proof of delivery, emails, logins, your policies as shown at checkout.

  5. 5

    Fill in Stripe’s evidence form

    Click “Counter dispute”. The form asks for specific items — product description, customer communication, shipping details, receipt, refund and cancellation policy — plus a free-text explanation. Put a short, point-by-point answer to the claim in the explanation and upload one compact document for each item. Stripe limits the total size of the files, so leave out anything that doesn’t prove a point.

  6. 6

    Submit before the “Respond by” date

    Check every file opens and reads clearly, then submit. A late response loses automatically, however strong it is.

  7. 7

    Wait for the bank’s decision

    The dispute shows as under review until the bank rules, then as won or lost, and Stripe emails you. If you win, the disputed amount is returned to your balance.

Writing the explanation yourself? Use our free chargeback rebuttal letter template.

The evidence that wins each kind of dispute

What wins depends on the customer’s claim, which the reason code names. Each reason code’s guide has its full checklist.

Fraud and unrecognized payments

Stripe reasons: fraudulent, unrecognized

  • The card checks on the payment: CVC and address (AVS) results, and 3D Secure authentication if it ran.
  • The customer’s IP address, device and account login behind the order.
  • Earlier payments from the same customer that weren’t disputed — for Visa, matching past payments can satisfy Compelling Evidence 3.0.
  • Delivery to the cardholder’s billing address, or proof they used what they bought (logins, downloads).
  • Messages showing the customer knew about the order.

Reason codes:Visa 10.4Mastercard 4837Mastercard 4863Amex F29Discover UA02

Product not received

Stripe reason: product not received

  • Carrier tracking showing delivery to the address the customer gave you, with signature or photo if you have it.
  • For digital goods or services: the access, download or login records after purchase.
  • The shipping address and delivery estimate shown at checkout.
  • Any message from the customer after delivery.

Reason codes:Visa 13.1Amex C08Discover RG

Not as described or defective

Stripe reason: product unacceptable

  • The product page as the customer saw it when they bought.
  • Your return policy, and proof the customer accepted it at checkout.
  • Your messages with the customer — especially a return or replacement you offered.
  • Proof the item matched its description: photos, specifications, quality checks.

Reason codes:Visa 13.3Mastercard 4853Amex C31Discover RM

Subscription canceled

Stripe reason: subscription canceled

  • The subscription terms the customer agreed to, and how to cancel.
  • Proof the customer didn’t cancel before this charge, or kept using the service after it.
  • Renewal reminders or receipts you sent.

Reason codes:Visa 13.2Mastercard 4841Amex C28

Credit not processed

Stripe reason: credit not processed

  • Your refund policy as shown at checkout.
  • The refund you already issued, with its date — or why no refund was owed (for example, the return never arrived).
  • Your messages with the customer about the return.

Reason codes:Visa 13.6Amex C02Discover RN2

Duplicate charge

Stripe reason: duplicate

  • Both payments side by side, showing they were separate orders.
  • A receipt and, for goods, a shipment for each order.
  • Or, if one was refunded, the refund and its date.

Reason codes:Visa 12.6.1Amex P08Discover DP

Where to find the evidence

The payment’s page in the Dashboard
CVC, address and 3D Secure results, the card’s country and the customer’s receipt.
The customer’s page
Their earlier payments, to show a history of undisputed orders.
Stripe Radar
The IP address and risk details behind the payment, where Radar has them.
Your own systems
Carrier tracking, emails and chats, account logins, and your policies as shown at checkout — Stripe doesn’t have these.

Mistakes that lose winnable disputes

  • Sending a generic proof of sale. A receipt shows the payment happened, which nobody disputes — answer the claim the reason code makes.
  • Tracking that only shows “shipped” or “in transit”. For a not-received dispute you need delivery, to the address the customer gave you.
  • Burying the bank in pages. An analyst reads dozens of cases a day: a short explanation and only the documents that prove it beat a 40-page dump.
  • Submitting before everything is in. You get one submission, so wait for the carrier’s proof of delivery or the customer’s old emails if they are on the way — but not past the deadline.
  • Arguing with the customer in the response. Stick to facts the bank can check, each tied to a document.

Stripe disputes FAQ

How long do I have to respond to a Stripe dispute?
Until the “Respond by” date shown on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. Stripe sets it ahead of the card network’s own limit, it can’t be extended, and a late response loses automatically.
Can I refund a payment after a Stripe dispute is opened?
No. Once a dispute is open, the payment can’t be refunded through Stripe, because the money has already been taken for the dispute. If the customer is right, accept the dispute instead. If they agree to withdraw it, still submit your evidence with their written withdrawal.
Can I change my evidence after submitting it to Stripe?
No. You can save evidence and come back to it before submitting, but once submitted it goes to the bank as it is. Wait until you have everything, but submit before the deadline.
Does Stripe decide who wins the dispute?
No. Stripe passes your evidence to the card network and the cardholder’s bank decides. Stripe then shows the outcome on the dispute and emails you.
Do I get the Stripe dispute fee back if I win?
That depends on your country. Stripe charges a dispute fee and, in some countries, a separate fee when you counter, which is returned if you win. Stripe’s pricing page lists the fees for your account.

Your next deadline is already counting down.

Open your first case free and have a cited, ready-to-send evidence package before the clock runs out.

Start your first case free

No card needed · Sign up with Google or email