PayPal disputes: the basics
- Where to find it
- In your PayPal business account, under disputes in the Resolution Center. PayPal also emails you when a case opens or changes stage.
- Deadline
- Shown on each case, and shorter once it becomes a claim. Miss it and the case closes in the buyer’s favour.
- Who decides
- Nobody, at the dispute stage: you and the buyer settle it. PayPal decides a claim. The card issuer decides a chargeback.
- Submissions
- Answer everything PayPal asks for in one response — you may not get a second chance to add to it.
- Fees
- PayPal may charge a fee on disputes and chargebacks, depending on your country and account. Check PayPal’s merchant fees page.
Check Seller Protection first
PayPal Seller Protection can cover item-not-received and unauthorized-payment cases on eligible physical goods — if you shipped to the address on the transaction details page and can show proof of shipment or delivery. It doesn’t cover “significantly not as described” cases. Each transaction’s details page says whether it is eligible.
How to respond, step by step
- 1
Work out which stage you’re in
A dispute, a claim or a chargeback. In a dispute you can message the buyer and settle it yourself. In a claim, PayPal asks you for specific information. In a chargeback, PayPal asks for evidence to pass to the card issuer.
- 2
Read the reason
PayPal cases are mostly item not received, significantly not as described, or unauthorized. Chargebacks also carry the card network’s reason code. The reason decides what evidence counts.
- 3
Try to settle it while it’s a dispute
Reply to the buyer in the case with facts: the tracking, the delivery date, what your policy offers. Offer a refund, partial refund or replacement if it’s fair. A dispute settled here never reaches a claim — and if you can’t agree, keep the conversation factual, because PayPal reads it if the buyer escalates.
- 4
Add tracking to the transaction
For physical goods, make sure the tracking number is on the PayPal transaction, and the shipping address matches the one on the transaction details page. That is what Seller Protection checks.
- 5
Collect the evidence for that reason
Use the checklist below. Pull what PayPal already has — the transaction details, the shipping address, the case messages — and add what lives elsewhere: carrier proof of delivery, emails, the listing as the buyer saw it, your policies.
- 6
Respond before the deadline
Answer exactly what PayPal asks for, upload clear documents and write a short explanation that answers the buyer’s claim point by point. For a chargeback, PayPal passes your response to the card issuer.
- 7
Wait for the decision — and appeal if you have new evidence
PayPal emails you when the case closes. If PayPal decides a claim against you and you have evidence it didn’t see, you can appeal from the case. A chargeback’s outcome is decided by the card issuer instead.
Writing the explanation yourself? Use our free chargeback rebuttal letter template.
The evidence that wins each kind of dispute
What wins depends on the customer’s claim, which the reason code names. Each reason code’s guide has its full checklist.
Item not received
PayPal reason: item not received
- Tracking on the PayPal transaction showing delivery to the address on the transaction details page.
- The carrier’s proof of delivery, with signature or photo if you have it.
- For digital goods or services: the access, download or login records after purchase.
- Any message from the buyer after delivery.
Reason codes:Visa 13.1Amex C08Discover RG
Significantly not as described
PayPal reason: significantly not as described
- The listing as the buyer saw it when they bought: photos, description, condition.
- Proof the item matched it: photos before shipping, specifications, quality checks.
- Your return policy, and the case messages where you offered a return or replacement.
- If PayPal asks the buyer to return the item: the return’s tracking, and what arrived back.
Reason codes:Visa 13.3Mastercard 4853Amex C31Discover RM
Unauthorized payment
PayPal reason: unauthorized transaction
- Delivery to the address on the transaction details page — for Seller Protection, it must match.
- The buyer’s earlier orders from you that weren’t disputed.
- The IP address, device and account login behind the order, from your store.
- Messages showing the buyer knew about the order.
Reason codes:Visa 10.4Mastercard 4837Mastercard 4863Amex F29Discover UA02
Subscription or billing agreement cancelled
PayPal case about a recurring payment
- The subscription terms the buyer agreed to, and how to cancel.
- Proof the buyer didn’t cancel before this payment, or kept using the service after it.
- Renewal reminders or receipts you sent.
Reason codes:Visa 13.2Mastercard 4841Amex C28
Refund not received
PayPal case or chargeback: credit not processed
- Your refund policy as shown when the buyer bought.
- The refund in PayPal with its date — or why no refund was owed (for example, the return never arrived).
- Your messages with the buyer about the return.
Reason codes:Visa 13.6Amex C02Discover RN2
Duplicate or incorrect charge
PayPal case or chargeback: billing error
- Both payments side by side, showing they were separate orders — or the amount the buyer agreed to.
- A receipt and, for goods, a shipment for each order.
- Or, if one was refunded, the refund and its date.
Reason codes:Visa 12.6.1Visa 12.5Amex P08Discover DP
Where to find the evidence
- The transaction details page
- The shipping address PayPal recorded, the tracking you added, and whether the payment is eligible for Seller Protection.
- The case in the Resolution Center
- Every message between you and the buyer — PayPal reads these if the case becomes a claim.
- Your activity
- The buyer’s earlier payments to you, and any refund you already sent.
- Outside PayPal
- The carrier’s proof of delivery, emails and chats, your listing and policies as they were, and login records from your store — PayPal doesn’t have these.
Mistakes that lose winnable disputes
- Shipping to an address that isn’t the one on the PayPal transaction. Seller Protection only covers the address PayPal recorded.
- Arguing with the buyer in the case messages. Stay factual — PayPal reads the whole conversation if the buyer escalates.
- Sending a generic proof of sale. A receipt shows the payment happened, which nobody disputes — answer the claim the reason code makes.
- Tracking that only shows “shipped” or “in transit”. For a not-received dispute you need delivery, to the address the customer gave you.
- Burying the bank in pages. An analyst reads dozens of cases a day: a short explanation and only the documents that prove it beat a 40-page dump.
PayPal disputes FAQ
- What is the difference between a PayPal dispute, a claim and a chargeback?
- A dispute is opened by the buyer in PayPal, and you can settle it with them directly. If you don’t, the buyer can escalate it to a claim, which PayPal decides. A chargeback is filed by the buyer with their card issuer, outside PayPal, and the issuer decides.
- How long do I have to respond to a PayPal claim?
- Until the deadline shown on the case in your PayPal account — it is shorter once a dispute becomes a claim. If you don’t respond in time, the case closes in the buyer’s favour.
- Does PayPal Seller Protection cover my case?
- It can cover item-not-received and unauthorized-payment cases on eligible physical goods, when you shipped to the address on the transaction details page and have proof of shipment or delivery. It doesn’t cover significantly-not-as-described cases. Each transaction’s details page shows its eligibility.
- Can I appeal a PayPal claim decision?
- Yes, if you have evidence PayPal didn’t see when it decided — such as proof of delivery that arrived later. You can appeal from the closed case in your PayPal account. A chargeback is decided by the card issuer, not PayPal.
- Why is money on hold in my PayPal account?
- When a case opens, PayPal holds the disputed amount until it is resolved. It is released to you if the case closes in your favour.